化学工程一篇文章的投稿周期



  • 转发自一个朋友!获得授权,很详细。

    Chemical Engineering Science

    化学工程领域TOP2期刊

    提交:7.18
    大修:9.12,需30天内返回
    大修返回:10.09
    小修:11.06
    小修返回:11.24
    接受:11.25

    审稿人1主要观点:However, the reviewer recommends that the manuscript should address several issues before being accepted for publication
    6个主要问题,3个格式、拼写问题

    审稿人2主要观点:最严厉。提及:The degree of novelty in this work is therefore considered to be minor. It may be an editorial decision whether this type of case study based work is publishable in CES.并附加6个主要问题

    审稿人3主要观点:无,不通不痒20个拼写问题、格式问题、参考文献问题,

    希望对大家有用!



  • Chemical Engineering Journal of Japan

    提交:7.28
    据稿:9.09

    审稿人1主要观点:Although this paper was well organized, this referee could not find sufficient novelty. Hence, this referee had no choice but to inform the authors that this article are unable to be accepted by this journal.
    6个非领域内的小问题,此审稿人应该非领域内的审稿人

    审稿人2主要观点:I think that this work is important and also recommend acceptance of this manuscript only after a minor revision并附加4个非常小的问题,此审稿人建议添加参考文献,参考文献文章的作者最近几年做了非常类似的研究,并发表在了AIChE


登录后回复
 

与 CFD 中国 的连接断开,我们正在尝试重连,请耐心等待